San Antonio, TX — February 2, 2024, one person was injured in a car accident at about 8 p.m. in the 8100 block of Bandera Road.

Authorities said a pedestrian was crossing the street when he was struck by a vehicle. The man was dressed in black, and the driver told police he didn't see him until it was too late.

The pedestrian, whose name has not been made public at this time, was hospitalized in critical condition after the crash, according to authorities.

The driver is not facing any charges or citations at this time.

The accident is still being investigated.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

When a pedestrian is seriously injured in a crash like the one on Bandera Road, the immediate focus is on his recovery. But beyond that, it’s crucial to determine exactly what happened and whether anything could have been done to prevent it. While this crash is still under investigation, there are three key questions that should always be addressed to ensure a full and fair understanding of the incident.

First, did the authorities conduct a thorough investigation? The available details suggest that police spoke to the driver and noted that the pedestrian was wearing dark clothing, which might have affected visibility. However, that’s only part of the equation. A proper investigation should also consider factors such as street lighting, traffic signals, the pedestrian’s location relative to a crosswalk and whether the driver’s headlights were functioning properly. Pedestrian crashes often involve complex dynamics, and a surface-level investigation may not capture all the critical details.

Second, has anyone considered the possibility that a vehicle defect contributed to the crash? While this case may seem straightforward, mechanical failures — such as faulty headlights, brake malfunctions or sensor issues in vehicles equipped with pedestrian detection systems — could be relevant. Authorities rarely inspect a vehicle for defects unless a driver explicitly reports a problem, which means an underlying issue could go undetected unless someone ensures the vehicle is examined.

Lastly, has all the electronic data related to the crash been collected? Modern vehicles often contain engine control modules that can provide insight into the driver’s speed, braking and reaction time leading up to the collision. Additionally, surveillance footage from nearby businesses, dash cams and even the driver’s or pedestrian’s cell phone data could provide valuable context. This type of evidence can be crucial in confirming exactly when the pedestrian became visible to the driver and whether there was an opportunity to avoid the crash. However, electronic data is often lost or overwritten if it isn’t secured quickly.

At the end of the day, any crash that results in serious injuries warrants a full and complete investigation. If law enforcement is unable to provide all the answers, it may be necessary for those affected to seek out independent experts who can. Those impacted by this incident deserve to know exactly what happened and why.