McLennan County, TX — June 26, 2024, Alice Swinnie was injured in a car accident at approximately 9:30 p.m. along Guthrie Drive.

According to authorities, 65-year-old Alice Swinnie was traveling in a northbound Nissan Murano on Guthrie Drive in in the vicinity south of the Huaco Lane intersection when the accident took place. Officials indicate that, for reasons yet to be confirmed, a southbound Toyota RAV4 failed to safely maintain its lane of travel. It allegedly veered left-of-center and was consequently involved in a collision with the left side of the Murano.

Swinnie reportedly sustained serious injuries as a result of the wreck. She was transported to a local medical facility by EMS in order to receive necessary treatment. It does not appear that anyone from the Toyota was hurt. Additional details pertaining to this incident are not available at this point in time.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

When one vehicle crosses the center line and strikes another head-on or side-to-side, it's easy to focus solely on the driver’s actions. But in serious injury crashes like this, it’s just as important to ask whether the full picture was captured—especially when the explanation isn't immediately clear.

1. Did the authorities thoroughly investigate the crash?
A nighttime crash involving a vehicle veering out of its lane should trigger more than just a basic report. Did investigators reconstruct the vehicle paths to determine how far the RAV4 drifted and whether the Murano had any chance to avoid the collision? Were lighting conditions, vehicle speeds, and positions documented in detail? These elements are crucial in lane-deviation crashes, yet they’re often left out when investigations are rushed or treated as routine.

2. Has anyone looked into the possibility that a vehicle defect caused the crash?
When a vehicle leaves its lane without apparent reason, mechanical failure has to be on the table. A sudden loss of steering control, a suspension failure, or an electronic malfunction in the RAV4 could explain the deviation. Similarly, if the Murano had any defects that prevented a defensive maneuver, that should be reviewed too. Without a thorough mechanical inspection of both vehicles, those possibilities could go unnoticed.

3. Has all the electronic data relating to the crash been collected?
Crash data from either vehicle could reveal critical moments before the impact. Did the RAV4 brake, swerve, or drift steadily? Did the Murano attempt to avoid the collision? That kind of information may be stored in onboard systems and can help fill in gaps that eyewitnesses can’t. Nearby homes or businesses might also have security cameras that captured the moment the vehicle left its lane. If that data hasn’t been preserved, the opportunity to fully understand the crash may have already passed.

When a serious injury occurs and the cause isn’t immediately obvious, surface-level answers don’t cut it. Getting to the truth requires asking harder questions—and making sure no angle is overlooked.

Takeaways:

• Lane-crossing crashes at night demand full reconstruction and documentation to determine vehicle paths and reaction time.
• Mechanical issues may cause unexpected lane departures and must be investigated through proper inspections.
• Vehicle data and nearby surveillance may offer the clearest evidence of what occurred in the final moments before impact.