McAllen, TX — January 17, 2025, Dale Baarda and Evelyn Baarda were killed in a car accident at about 12:45 p.m. on South 10th Street.

Authorities said a Buick SUV and a motorcycle collided in the 1700 block of South 10th Street, forcing the motorcycle to crash into a light pole.

Evelyn Baarda, 76, who was the passenger on the motorcycle, was pronounced dead at the scene of the crash, according to authorities. Her husband, Dale Baarda, 78, died after being transported to a local hospital.

No other injuries were reported, but authorities said the Buick driver was arrested for driving without a license.

The accident is still being investigated.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

When I read about the crash in McAllen, Texas, that claimed the lives of two motorcycle riders, my thoughts are with the family and loved ones mourning such a profound loss. As is often the case, the initial reports provide only a glimpse of what happened, leaving many questions unanswered. To fully understand and address the circumstances surrounding this tragedy, it’s essential to focus on three critical questions: Did authorities conduct a thorough investigation? Could a vehicle defect have contributed to the crash? And has all relevant electronic data been collected?

The first question is whether authorities thoroughly investigated the crash. Determining the exact sequence of events requires a detailed reconstruction of the collision, including an examination of the crash scene, the vehicles involved and witness statements. While authorities have reported that the Buick driver was driving without a license, this does not necessarily explain how or why the crash occurred. Critical factors such as visibility, road conditions and the actions of both drivers must be closely examined. A comprehensive investigation ensures that every possible cause is considered.

The second question to consider is whether a vehicle defect played a role in the crash. Motorcycle collisions are often attributed to driver behavior, but mechanical or design failures in either the motorcycle or the Buick could also have been a factor. For example, if the motorcycle’s brakes, tires or steering system failed, this could have contributed to the crash or made it impossible for the rider to avoid the collision. Similarly, defects in the Buick — such as malfunctioning brakes or acceleration issues — should be examined. Identifying these issues requires a forensic examination of both vehicles, which must be preserved to allow for proper testing. Unfortunately, these steps are often overlooked, leaving critical evidence unexamined.

The third question is whether all relevant electronic data has been collected. Both the Buick SUV and the motorcycle may contain valuable data in their engine control modules (ECMs). This information can provide insights into vehicle speed, braking and other factors immediately prior to the collision. Additionally, nearby surveillance cameras or cell phone records may reveal important details, such as whether the drivers had a clear view of one another or whether distraction was involved. Preserving and analyzing this data quickly is crucial, as it can degrade or be lost if not retrieved promptly.

Ultimately, answering these three questions is essential to understanding how and why this crash occurred. The families of those affected deserve clarity and accountability. Investigations that leave no stone unturned not only provide answers to those mourning a loss but also contribute to safer roads by identifying potential hazards or oversights that could lead to future crashes. For everyone involved, a thorough and complete investigation is the first step toward justice and closure.