Claude, TX — January 19, 2025, James Smith was killed and Holley Fifield, Riley Fifield and a child were injured in a car accident at about 11 p.m. on State Highway 207.

Authorities said a 2002 Acura RDX collided head-on with a 2023 Hyundai Santa Fe, which rolled several times. The Acura skidded into the ditch on the west side of the road, partially ejecting the driver.

Acura driver James Smith, 40, of Amarillo died at the scene, about three miles north of Claude, according to authorities.

Hyundai driver Holley Fifield, 24, and a baby girl suffered serious injuries in the crash, authorities said. Another passenger, Riley Fifield, sustained non-life-threatening injuries. All three were hospitalized after the crash.

The accident is still under investigation.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

When examining a fatal crash like this one, it is essential to address three key questions: Did the authorities thoroughly investigate the crash? Has anyone looked into the possibility that a vehicle defect contributed to the incident? Has all electronic data from the vehicles involved been collected and analyzed? These questions are critical for uncovering the full picture of what happened and ensuring all contributing factors are identified.

While the crash is still under investigation, it is crucial to evaluate whether all potential factors are being properly examined.

The first question focuses on the thoroughness of the investigation. A head-on collision often involves one vehicle crossing into oncoming traffic. Did investigators analyze whether either driver lost control due to environmental factors, such as poor lighting, road conditions or lane markings? Were any witnesses interviewed to provide insight into the actions of the vehicles prior to the collision? A comprehensive investigation must also include a review of the roadway itself to determine whether any hazards or design flaws could have contributed to the crash.

The second question involves the potential role of vehicle defects. Mechanical issues, such as brake failure, steering malfunctions or tire blowouts, can cause drivers to lose control of their vehicles. Given the Acura's reported loss of control and skidding into a ditch, it’s essential to inspect the vehicle for any signs of mechanical failure. Similarly, the Hyundai’s rollover raises questions about its stability and crashworthiness. Was the Hyundai’s safety equipment, such as airbags and seatbelts, functioning as designed? These factors are especially important in understanding the severity of the injuries sustained by its occupants.

The third question emphasizes the importance of collecting and analyzing electronic data. Modern vehicles, including the 2023 Hyundai Santa Fe, are equipped with engine control modules (ECMs) that record key data points such as speed, steering inputs and braking activity. If the Acura’s ECM is intact, it could provide valuable insights into whether the driver attempted to avoid the collision or if a mechanical issue played a role. Analyzing this data is critical for reconstructing the sequence of events leading up to the crash.

Answering these three questions ensures that no detail is overlooked in the investigation. While it is often easy to assume driver error as the primary cause in head-on collisions, other factors — such as vehicle defects, environmental conditions or incomplete data analysis — can significantly influence the outcome. By taking a comprehensive approach, investigators can provide clarity about what happened for those affected by this crash.